Fiber Internet vs. Cable vs. DSL: Which Is Right For You?

Want to get more out of your home internet?

Check availability 

It wasn't that long ago-25, maybe 30 years-that homeowners only had one option for their Internet connectivity: dial-up. Thankfully, dial-up (and the sound it made while slowly connecting to the Internet) is a thing of the past.

Today, we have choices. But deciding between fiber Internet vs. cable vs. DSL may feel a bit confusing at times. While each of these connections will get you online, they vary in how they do so and how well they deliver the speed being purchased.

If you're looking for help figuring out which Internet connection is right for you, we're here. Ahead, we're breaking down the differences between cable Internet, fiber, and DSL so you can find the option that best suits your needs. Read on for the need-to-knows.

Fiber Optic vs. DSL vs. Cable Internet Speed Difference

What’s The Difference Between Cable, Fiber, and DSL?

DSL, a Digital Subscriber Line, is one of the first Internet technologies. DSL uses your local phone line to connect to the Internet and transfer data. It is similar to dial-up Internet except it uses different frequencies for your phone Internet, so using both devices at the same time won't slow your connection.

Cable internet works through your modem, via coaxial cable. The modem connects to either a computer or a router through an Ethernet wire. Most houses utilize a router that broadcasts a WiFi signal, allowing you to access the Internet.

Fiber optic Internet, most commonly known as "fiber", is the other wired Internet connection we'll be examining. Fiber is a high-speed option that works through data being transmitted by light through the fiber optic rather than electricity.

Between DSL, cable, and fiber optic, DSL is the slowest. If you choose DSL, your download speeds would be around 1 to 7 megabits per second. While this might be considered slow to some, this speed is a good amount for basic usage such as surfing the Internet, email, or standard music and video streaming.

DSL would be too slow for high-definition videos, especially if you have multiple devices connected to your WiFi. Some Internet service providers do offer DSL packages with speeds up to 20 Mbps, which is slightly faster, but still is only best suited for fundamental Internet use.

The main advantages of DSL are that it's widely available and is the most affordable option when compared to cable and fiber optic. However, the disadvantage of DSL is that it's the slowest of the bunch.

DSL vs Fiber vs Cable Internet

As mentioned, cable Internet, fiber Internet, and DSL (which stands for digital subscriber line) will all grant you a connection to the Internet. But that's where their similarities end. Keep reading for our comparison of DSL vs fiber vs cable Internet.

DSL Internet

Like dial-up Internet, DSL connects to the Internet via your home's landline (phone line). However, where dial-up Internet uses the same frequency for both phone and Internet connections, DSL uses two different frequencies. Effectively, that means you can use your phone and access the Internet simultaneously, without dropping or delaying your connection.

And because it connects via your phone line, DSL is widely available. The downside: It's slow, with download speeds maxing out at around 200 Mbps. These slower DSL speeds may be fine for an individual surfing the web but are less capable of handling streaming, gaming, or more intensive Internet usage.

Key Facts:

  • Slow upload and download speeds
  • Not ideal for larger households
  • Only enough bandwidth to support basic Internet surfing
  • Speeds decrease when wires are long

Fiber optic Internet

Fiber optic Internet connects to the web via fiber optic cables, which use light and very thin glass fibers to send and receive signals. With "Fiber to the Home" (known as FTTH), these cables run directly from your Internet service provider's network to your home. This is the most advanced and fastest option for Internet connectivity.

Fiber Internet speeds vary, but some plans offer speeds of up to 8,000 Mbps. Upload speeds are important specifically in relation to sending large files and participating in video chats-which makes fiber Internet an ideal choice for people who work from home. However, fiber optic Internet is currently only available in some regions. If you're interested, you can check if fiber is available for your household here.

Key Facts:

  • Symmetrical upload and download speeds
  • Capable of supporting several devices simultaneously
  • Speeds are consistent even when fibers are very long
  • Not (yet) available everywhere
  • Typically a more expensive option

Cable Internet

Cable Internet is the most widely-used type of broadband connection. It uses cable wires (hence the name) to provide an Internet connection and offers fast speeds-generally up to 1Gig. At these speeds, even households with multiple devices connected to the WiFi will be able to perform to the best of their capabilities.

Key Facts:

  • Fast upload and download speeds
  • More affordable than fiber Internet
  • Can support multiple devices simultaneously
  • Not available everywhere
  • Speeds are consistent even when cables are long

Is DSL More Reliable Than Cable Internet?

DSL can be quite slow, which means it isn't always reliable when you need to use the Internet and get an immediate answer or enjoy an episode of your favorite streaming show. The signal also weakens the further you are from the source. As such, it's not as dependable as higher-speed options like cable and fiber Internet, which offer great upload and download speeds and can support several devices simultaneously.

Is Cable Internet Better Than DSL?

If you have the option to choose between cable Internet or DSL, we recommend the former. There are a few reasons for this: It's faster, it's better able to support multiple devices, and the speeds are consistent even at long distances from the source. Overall, cable is the better option of the two.

Is Fiber Internet Better Than DSL and Cable?

If it’s available in your area, fiber Internet is the best option for your Internet connection, thanks to its exceptional upload and download speeds, ability to support various high-speed devices at once, and the fact that speeds are consistent even at long distances from the source.

As it becomes more widely available, we expect fiber Internet to be the most popular Internet option among homeowners and business owners alike.

Cable Internet vs. Fiber vs. DSL: Which Should You Choose?

Ultimately, cable and fiber optic Internet are excellent options for those seeking a reliable Internet connection. Both offer fast speeds and the capacity to support several devices or users at once. If you're still struggling to decide between cable vs. fiber (assuming both options are available to you), consider how you use the Internet and determine what speeds you require to help inform your decision. Either way, you'll enjoy fast speeds, low latency, and a 99.9% reliable connection with Optimum Internet.*

Are you getting everything you need from your home internet? Explore Optimum’s Internet plans

*99.9% reliability claim excludes outages caused by external events and scheduled maintenance.

You May Also Like

Check availability

See if Optimum is available for your home.



See if Optimum is available for your home:

Find special offers in your area

Already an Optimum customer?

Sign in to add enhanced services to your account now.